Module 4: Facilitating and observing user research
These training resources accompany our 2-day practical training course, Learn to do user research.
The course includes conversations and activities to help you apply everything you learn and an opportunity to get feedback from our experienced user researchers. It will give you all the skills you need to start or develop your career as a user researcher.
See more details and sign up for Learn to do user research.
This module is the 4th of 6 modules in Learn to do user research
- Framing the right research problem
- Planning and designing user research
- Recruiting research participants in a mindful and ethical way
- Facilitating and observing user research
- Analysing research findings
- Turning research findings into persuasive and usable outputs
By the end of this module you’ll be able to
- create an environment where people feel comfortable to talk honestly and openly, to get the most out of your research
- turn colleagues and stakeholders into good research observers to capture insights and get buy-in
- deal with inappropriate participant behaviour and feel confident ending a session early if you need to
- protect your participant and make sure they feel safe
- effectively introduce and wrap up a research session
Conducting a user research session – Who’s involved
A research session usually involves:
- the research participant or participants
- a user researcher who facilitates the session
- an observer or observers from your team who help to take notes
The role of the facilitator in a research session
In a research session the facilitator is the person who interacts with the participant(s) the most. Their role is to introduce the session to the participant, ask questions from the discussion guide, and focus on what the participant is saying or doing so they can ask follow up questions or set tasks.
The role of an observer in a research session
Observers are responsible for making sure you, the researcher, capture everything you need to in the limited time you get with a participant. Ideally, your observers will also continue to work with you after the research session when you’re conducting analysis, to help you figure out what you’ve learned and how to describe it.
You might have 1 observer or multiple observers in a research session. Make sure you think critically about how many is appropriate and the impact it may have on your participant.
We’d recommend that you offer the observation role to as many people as you can across your various research sessions. We always encourage the people we’re working with day-to-day on the project to observe research, but you could also include senior stakeholders from the business who should have an interest in your problem.
Top tip! The observation role can be a very useful way of engaging people who are otherwise quite difficult to engage with or resistant to the changes that might come from the research – think back to Module 1 and our discussions about negotiation.
How to facilitate a research session
Facilitating a research session can be a bit tricky sometimes. But remember that some research is better than no research. Even if you don’t do everything the way you planned you’ll still learn something.
As well as asking questions and setting tasks you’ll also need to:
- manage timings
- build a rapport with the participant
- keep the participant safe
- clearly communicate information
- remain impartial
- leave pauses for participants to think
- actively listen
It’s a balancing act. You want your participant to feel safe and comfortable but you also need to avoid biassing them by being too encouraging or giving too much away.
How to actively listen
Active listening is a skill that means you stay focussed on what someone is saying and show them that you hear and empathise with them. You should:
- be fully present in the conversation
- notice and use non-verbal cues
- reflect back what your participant says
- withhold judgement
Active listening helps reassure the participant that their contribution is valuable and helps the researcher to adapt the session based on what they’re learning.
How to observe a user research session
When it comes to analysing your findings after a research session, you’ll find that you learn more when you revisit exactly what the participant said and did. So when you observe research, it’s important to capture the right level of detail to come back to.
- Transcribe the session if you can, either manually or using a transcription tool
- Write quotes down word-for-word (unless they could be used to identify the person)
- Note any biases the participant shows, like if they’re an expert in a topic
- Note any behaviours that might give you insight into their experiences, like whether they seem nervous or confident
- Note any themes or topics as you see them emerge
- Write down any user needs (not wants!) that you observe – we’ll talk more about how to identify user needs on the course
How to introduce a research session
You should allow 10 to 15 minutes at the start of a research session for an introduction. Your aim is to help your participant to feel psychologically safe and comfortable taking part. You can read more about curating psychological safety in research here.
We have a pattern for introducing a research session, which you’re welcome to use. There are 3 core elements to it:
- Explaining the purpose of the session
- Giving the participant information to help them feel psychologically safe, like how they can pause or end the session if they want to
- Letting the participant know how you’ll be storing and protecting their personal data
You should also consider psychological safety in advance of the research session. Think about any elements of your specific research project that may make someone feel unsafe.
Example: Rachael (a cis woman) and Cam (a cis man) worked together as researchers on a project looking into people’s experiences of misogyny. Before their research sessions they gave participants the opportunity to opt to speak to a woman, in case they’d feel more comfortable.
How to handle things going wrong in a research session
Expect the unexpected
When we do research we’re working with people we don’t know, so we can’t fully plan for what might go wrong in a session. What we can do is plan for how we might handle realistic scenarios based on the things we do know or can reasonably expect given the nature of the research. We always recommend doing this with someone else in your team. It’s easier to think about scenarios and they may feel less daunting working through them together.
Here are a few examples of circumstances that could impact your session:
- Your participant doesn’t speak English as a first language.
- Your participant is vulnerable. There are lots of things that may make someone vulnerable and it changes with the context of your research. For example, children, adults with learning disabilities, people with uncertain immigration status.
- Your participant is distracted by their environment.
- Your research is focussed on a particularly polarising topic.
- Your research asks participants to recall distressing events.
If something goes wrong and it’s a scenario you haven’t planned for, the best thing you can do is be a human, forget about the research, and focus on looking after the participant and yourself.
How to end a research session early
There are a couple of reasons you may want to end a research session early:
- The participant’s behaviour is inappropriate and you need to protect yourself or any observers.
- The participant is unsafe.
If a participant is behaving inappropriately
A participant may have joined to complain about your organisation or your project, or they may say something inappropriate during the research session.
In these scenarios we take the following steps:
- Pause the session and try to redirect the participant back to the right topic.
- If they continue their poor behaviour, stop the session. If you feel comfortable, go through the end-of-session information you’ve prepared. If not, you can email this information to them after the session.
- Depending on the situation, consider:
- What to do with any research data you’ve collected
- Whether to pay the participant any pre-agreed incentive
If a participant or others are unsafe
You may observe that a participant is in a state of distress or danger, or that they may be putting someone else in danger. For example, they may have dialled into a call while driving, continue talking to you while a fire alarm is going off, or seem upset when answering questions.
This is what we do to intervene:
- Pause the session and the recording to check on the participant. Ask them if they’d like to take a break or stop the session.
- If they indicate that they’re going to harm themselves or others, try to identify their location and contact an emergency service.
We have a pattern to guide you through ending a session if a participant is in distress.
How to end a successful user research session
How to wrap up a session
We have a pattern for ending a research session that you might find handy.
At the end of your research session, before you stop recording, you may want to ask your participant some general questions, like:
- if there’s anything else they’d like to share with you on the topics you’ve covered during the session
- if they have any questions for you
There are also some essential points you need to cover with your participant before you part ways, but we think it’s best to stop the recording before you go through these:
- Tell them the session is over and that you’ve stopped recording.
- Check they’re still clear on the consent terms.
- Check they understand what (if anything) they should expect to do next.
- Tell them how to contact you if they have any concerns or questions.
- Make sure they’re ending the session feeling as OK as they were at the start.
How to debrief with observers
It’s a good idea to debrief with your observers after the session, while it’s still fresh in your minds. During a debrief you might:
- check in on each other – research can take a toll so it’s always good to check everyone’s feeling OK
- talk through what you’ve learned and think about what it means
There are probably some administrative tasks to chat about too.
If you’re doing remote research over a phone or video call, it’s always a good idea to start a new call for the debrief. You don’t want a participant to rejoin while you’re debriefing, or even worse, access a transcription of the debrief you held on their session.
Next module →
Go to Module 5: Analysing research findings.
Sign up for ‘Learn to do user research’
Our 2-day practical training course, Learn to do user research, gives you a complete foundation in key user research skills.
Join experienced user researchers at Paper to learn key skills and put them into practice, with lots of opportunity for questions and feedback.
Follow Paper on LinkedIn