Skip to content
A picture of Rachael
Rachael
User researcher

12 min read

Follow Paper on LinkedIn

Module 3: Recruiting research participants in a mindful and ethical way

These training resources accompany our 2-day practical training course, Learn to do user research.

The course includes conversations and activities to help you apply everything you learn and an opportunity to get feedback from our experienced user researchers. It will give you all the skills you need to start or develop your career as a user researcher.

See more details and sign up for Learn to do user research.

This module is the 3rd of 6 modules in Learn to do user research

  1. Framing the right research problem
  2. Planning and designing user research
  3. Recruiting research participants in a mindful and ethical way
  4. Facilitating and observing user research
  5. Analysing research findings
  6. Turning research findings into persuasive and usable outputs

By the end of this module you’ll be able to

  • identify and find the best people to research with, understanding the factors you need to consider
  • design screeners to find people with specific characteristics, and ask for this information in a sensitive way
  • describe your research so that people want to take part but without introducing bias
  • decide when a participation incentive is helpful or appropriate
  • adhere to the GDPR when collecting, storing and using people’s information

Recruiting research participants mindfully and ethically – Why it matters

When we’re recruiting people for research we need to think about lots of different elements to make sure that we’re successful, our recruitment is conducted ethically, and that we’re adhering to data regulations (the GDPR). A good recruitment drive includes much more than simply contacting the people you want to take part.

You’ll need a carefully honed recruitment plan to help you get a good response rate, and that will rely on getting a number of elements right like contacting the right people, explaining the research properly, and lots more.

You’ll often need to tweak your plan after you’ve launched your recruitment campaign, depending on the level of response you’re getting.

As researchers our primary responsibility is to the participants who take part in our research. We’re asking them to share things with us and in return we need to explain how we’ll treat them and the things they share.

Considerations like making sure we have informed consent not only help us build trust with our participants but they also make sure we have a legal basis for processing their data. We need to make sure we understand and adhere to the regulations around collecting, processing and storing personal information.

How to find people to contact

Recruitment starts with a conversation about where you’re going to get the contact details for potential participants.

You need to consider whether it’s appropriate for you to invite them to take part in research. Ideally, people should have given consent to be contacted about potential research opportunities. You may want to review any existing policies around customer data, specifically looking at what they have or haven’t consented to before contacting them about research opportunities.

You can also use existing sources of data for contacting users, like support tickets or data in any CRM (customer relationship management) tool, as long as your first contact includes information on how people can opt out of receiving emails like this in the future.

If you have time, you can ask colleagues in other areas of the business to ask for consent to be contacted about research from customers who contact them. This could be your sales, support, or marketing teams.

On the Learn to do user research course, we’ll explore some additional considerations for finding people for research, like:

  • the biases different types of data can introduce to your research, like if you’re only contacting people who’ve raised support tickets
  • using recruitment agencies to find people
  • building networks of organisations who can help you find participants with specific characteristics
  • the pros and cons of asking potential participants to share your invitation to take part with with others

How to describe the purpose of your research without introducing bias

When you contact a participant about taking part in your research, you need to be able to succinctly describe the purpose of the research. This should be one sentence to summarise what you’re doing and why.

This allows potential participants to understand what they’re being asked to take part in, see why it’s relevant to them and make an informed decision about whether they’d like to take part.

The tricky part is how you make sure you don’t bias someone too much. You could bias someone by being overly descriptive of what outcomes you’re hoping to achieve, or by giving away the characteristics you’ll be screening participants for.

You should avoid telling potential participants:

  • exactly who you want to speak to
  • what you’re hoping they’ll talk about
  • what questions you’ll ask
  • the specific problems you’re looking into
  • definitions of terminology specific to the topic you’re researching

How to decide whether to offer an incentive for participation

Sometimes you need something extra to incentivise participants to take part in your research. While financially incentivising people can help, it’s not the only, and not always the best, way to encourage people to sign up to your study.

There are a lot of reasons to think before you send people money for taking part in research.

  • People with a benefits cap could be penalised for receiving the extra income.
  • People who struggle with technology may not be able to use online vouchers and will need a physical alternative.
  • Colleagues often can’t receive taxable benefits.

People may want to take part in your research regardless of any financial incentive so they can get early access to new features, or simply because they want to help make things better. You might also consider offering to make a donation to a charity of your participant’s choosing.

There are also a couple of specific scenarios where you’d have extra things to consider:

  • If you’re doing research with children – how do you pitch incentives to them and their guardians?
  • If you’re doing research with people who need assistance from a friend due to language or technology barriers – can you incentivise them both?

How to adhere to the GDPR

It’s important to take the time to understand the UK GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation) and how it may affect your research activities.

You may also have participants in regions that have different data protection legislation that you need to consider.

The GDPR provides 8 rights for individuals in relation to their data. These rights should form the basis of any processes you set up for collecting, storing and using participants’ data. Participants and potential participants should be able to contact you about any of these rights at any time.

The GDPR covers 2 types of data: personal data and special category data.

  • Personal data is information that relates to an identified or identifiable individual.
  • Special category data is personal data that needs more protection because it’s sensitive.

We also talk about the following kinds of information:

  • Personally identifiable information (PII) is information that can be used to tell an individual’s identity.
  • Anonymised information is information that has been permanently stripped of any PII (like name or customer number), and is therefore no longer considered personal data.
  • Pseudonymised information is information where PII has been replaced or removed, but those identifiers are still held separately. This is still considered personal data because the means to identify the individual still exist.

How to decide what data to collect

At the start of a project you’ll need to think about the data you’ll collect during recruitment and what you plan to use it for.

This is because first and foremost, you should not be collecting any data that you don’t plan to use – this is covered by the GDPR but it’s also just good practice.

You also need to plan ahead a little bit so that you don’t miss out on the chance to collect data that you may want to use in your analysis later on.

If ever in doubt, don’t collect it. You can always go back and ask for permission to use or collect more data, and it’s better to do it that way than end up with a mass of data that you shouldn’t have taken.

The types of data you’ll need

It helps us to think about three different types of data that we’re likely to need during the recruitment process:

  • Monitoring data – Data you use to monitor how successful (or not) your recruitment process is
  • Eligibility data – Data you use to decide if someone fits the criteria to participate in your research
  • Research data – Data you collect during recruitment that you might combine or compare with the data you get from research sessions later on

Whatever data you collect should be processed in one of these 3 ways. If you’re not processing the data you shouldn’t keep it. You should also decide when you’ll want to destroy the data so that you’re not keeping unused data for any longer than is necessary.

On the course, we’ll go through a case study that shows how data could work across all 3 of these categories.

How to use eligibility data to screen for participants

We often need to speak to people with distinct characteristics to gain the best insights to answer our research questions. These characteristics may be about someone’s habits, interests, their job role or their background.

For us to feel confident we’re speaking to the right people, we need to understand if the people signing up to participate have the characteristics we need.

To do this we need to design questions into our recruitment process. It’s a delicate balance between writing a question that’s specific enough to give us confidence about selecting someone based on their answer, but open enough that the potential participant can’t easily tell what answer we’re looking for.

How to ask people about personal information

As an organisation you can gain a lot from asking people about characteristics that may typically exclude them from spaces, but those providing the information often don’t benefit from sharing this data with you. These can be sensitive subjects and are not always treated with the respect they deserve.

It’s important that we design screener questions in a sensitive and empathetic way, explaining why we’re asking and how we’ll use the data.

When designing questions you should include as many options as possible, allow people to add their own more appropriate answer, and allow people to skip a question unless it’s absolutely essential for your research.

At Paper we have standard patterns for asking about gender, ethnicity and health conditions. You’re welcome to use these. If you do, we’d love to get your feedback on how they’re worded and how they work for you.

Consent is a way for us to describe the rules and protections we have in place to keep our participants safe, and for the participants to decide if they’re confident in taking part based on those rules and protections.

Most importantly, gaining informed consent is the way that researchers make sure they have a legal basis for processing an individual’s data. So you need to do this to ensure you’re adhering to the GDPR.

Getting informed consent is not a barrier to doing good research! It’s actually the first step to building trust with your participant – and building trust with participants is how you do good research.

A consent form should be easy to understand, easy to access, and empowering.

A consent form should not be demanding, complex, or confusing.

This may seem simple, but it can be hard when there are complex topics to cover and you don’t know much about the participants.

Your form should be in a format that the participant can keep for reference, and include:

  • a description of the purpose of the research
  • a description of how you’ll be facilitating the research
  • an explanation of how you plan to store, use and protect the participant’s data
  • ways the participant can adapt the session to meet their needs
  • a way for the participant to get in contact about their data
  • a way for the participant to raise a complaint about the research

How to store participant data safely and securely

When we talk about storing participant data, we need to remember that the data of any potential participants should be treated with the same care that you’d treat the data of participants who have already signed up.

Any personal data or special category data should only be accessible by the research team and should not be shared without consent.

You should keep your list of who has taken part in which study separate from your main recruitment list to avoid identifying participants. You may however want to highlight when you last contacted someone so that they’re not overburdened by requests for research.


Next module →

Go to Module 4: Facilitating and observing user research

Sign up for ‘Learn to do user research’

Our 2-day practical training course, Learn to do user research, gives you a complete foundation in key user research skills.

Join experienced user researchers at Paper to learn key skills and put them into practice, with lots of opportunity for questions and feedback.

See dates and sign up