Publishing data about representation, retention, pay and promotion at Paper (2021)
We want to make Paper a more welcoming and diverse place to work. One thing we’ve learned is we should publish data about some important aspects at Paper. These areas are representation, retention, pay and promotion.
By starting this work we’ve realised that some information we do collect, and some we don’t, and how we collect it needs to change. Rather than avoid sharing anything for an entire year while we get our data collection sorted, we wanted to publish something. It’s not perfect, but it’s a start. We’ll continue to publish updates at least annually.
Representation
We don’t collect data for the Paper team on gender, age, sexual orientation, disability, socio-economic status, religion. We’re cautious, we never want to collect data until we are 100% about why we need it, how it will be used, and how we will keep it safe.
As part of our anti-racism strategy we do collect some ethnicity data about freelancers and job applicants who apply to work with Paper, we use this to monitor our recruitment process and make iterative changes to improve it. The consent form for this data currently says:
We only record this information for Paper's equality monitoring and is entirely optional. We won't record this information without this consent and it does not influence our hiring process.
We constantly work on improving our diversity at Paper from within and also work with racial equity consultants to understand racial bias within Paper. This data is very valuable for targeted improvement within the business.
Email join@paper.studio if you have any questions.
We’re going to change this to specifically state our intention to publish the aggregate data every year to benchmark our recruitment process and hold ourselves to account publically. Here’s the revised wording we’ll be using.
We record information about your ethnic group for Paper’s equality monitoring and reporting, it is entirely optional. We won’t record this information without your consent and it does not influence our hiring process.
Data is collated and reported anonymously as part of our commitment to publishing benchmarked data on recruitment, representation, retention, pay and promotion.
The data is very valuable to help us improve the business. Collated data will be used by the people doing analysis, while your personal information will only be accessible by the people handling recruitment.
We’ve got a lot to do in the remainder of this year to get things in better shape. We need to do this and we’re committed to doing it.
Our hope for the next time we publish data in 2022 is that we’ll publish something that we can start benchmarking ourselves against.
Retention
Retention is a weird word, sounds like we own people. We don’t, we’re grateful people have chosen to stay at Paper.
No-one has yet decided that Paper isn’t the right place for them. Writing those words makes us very happy indeed. It’s only a matter of time before this changes, and when it does we will be thoughtful, reflective, and supportive.
Below is the retention percentage of employees:
- 2018 - 100%
- 2019 - 100%
- 2020 - 100%
- 2021 - 100%
As we wrote this it stirred some questions. Why is retention important? Why don’t we celebrate when people go onto better or different things? Should we be reporting on how good Paper is as a place to learn and grow before moving on?
Maybe we’ll write about that one day.
Employee pay
Our first employee joined in 2018 and we’re still a small team, growing steadily. Salaries for employees have increased each year.
The percentages below have been calculated by the difference between average salary from 1 January to 31 December each year. Numbers have been rounded down.
Average salary annual increase:
- 2018 - 8.5% increase
- 2019 - 9% increase
- 2020 - 5% increase*
- 2021 - 9% increase
*We held some salary reviews in late 2019 and early 2020. All data has been captured as 2020 for this article.
Director pay
There’s three directors at Paper. There’s no reason to hide this information, nor do we want to group things in with the above employee figures.
We haven’t increased our pay over the past few years. Whilst Paper is a commercial business, we didn’t start it for purely financial reasons (see this recent article) and we have always prioritised reinvesting profit into the business and Paper’s savings.
We were in a privileged position where we could fund and invest in the creation of Paper and we paid ourselves a minimal salary for the first few years. It means our figures jump rapidly in the first three years to bring ourselves to a liveable salary.
The percentage has been calculated by the difference between pay from 1 April to 31 March following each year. Numbers have been rounded down.
- 2018 - 14.5% increase
- 2019 - 25.5% increase
- 2020 - 0% increase
- 2021 - 0% increase
Promotion
As a business that’s adopted a flat-as-possible structure, we don’t distinguish between levels of roles or any real kind of significant hierarchy. However, as directors of Paper (Jon, Mark and Cam) do have responsibilities that come from being directors of a limited business. We are constantly in the process of making things flatter, we continually ask where the power is and can we shift it to the whole team.
We don’t use labels like ‘associate’, ‘junior’ or ‘senior’ which makes reporting on promotion pretty hard. We are entirely open - and want to encourage - the leadership at Paper to change over time. This needs to happen for us to develop, adapt, grow and continue being a welcoming and diverse place. We value progress of capabilities, and disciplines, we don’t value job titles as indicators of someone’s status.
Promotions to date:
- 2018 - none
- 2019 - none
- 2020 - none
- 2021 - none
In January 2021 we introduced a capability framework which has two types of progression:
- Core Paper capabilities that go from Learning, to Owning, to Leading
- Specialism capabilities which go from Learning, to Practising, to Specialising
In a year’s time we expect to be able to track this benchmark of capability progression.
We’ve got some good work to be getting on with. Best get cracking.
If you’ve kept an eye on Paper over the years, you’ll know we’re ok with often opening ourselves up to critique and comments. If you read this and want to get in touch, we’d love to hear from you.
Follow Paper on LinkedIn