Paper’s principles, where’s the evidence?
We were recently lucky enough to get to work with Dr Muna Abdi to help us create our anti-racism strategy. In one of our first chats with Muna about Paper’s background we talked about our principles and she asked, “where is the evidence (behind the principles)?”, which is a fair question.
We founded Paper 5 years ago. Before it even had a name Jon, Mark and I (the three founders) agreed 4 principles:
- We value our principles more than money
- Our profit funds innovation
- We value leg ups and free work as much as paid work
- Paper is self funded and independent
We wanted then, as we do now, for Paper to be a welcoming place to work. Our team, our partners, and our clients should know where we stand and should be able to see evidence that we stick to our principles.
I think we haven’t talked about the evidence partly out of modesty and partly because it seems a bit preachy and overly worthy. We’re not a boastful company but we are quietly confident about our principles. But it is only fair that people who wish to work with us should be able to look at the evidence and make a judgement for themselves.
So the rest of this article is just some of the evidence. I’ve tried to limit it to one or two examples for each principle to keep this article relatively short. If you ever chat with someone from Paper feel free to ask us, or even challenge us, to provide more evidence, we’ve been collecting it since that chat with Muna and have plenty of examples to share.
The “Mama principle”
Principle 1: We value our principles more than money
I’ve recently been working with Paper person Faye to rewrite our principles and check that they make sense (more about that in a future article). Faye calls the first principle, “We value our principles more than money”, the “Mama principle”. It’s a superseding principle, when all else fails this is the principle we fall back on so there’s a lot of evidence behind it.
For example…
We’ve grown very cautiously
“We value our principles more than money” might sound like we don’t care about money or we’re flippant about it, it’s actually the opposite. We have a very cautious respect for how money can influence our decisions. We know businesses who grow too big and too quickly when short on work have taken on compromised work to pay the wage bill.
In our first year we were skint but since then we’ve always maintained a salary pot that allows us to operate for a minimum of 6 months without any income. It’s meant that whenever work slowed down the team could remain confident their jobs were safe and their roles wouldn’t change.
Selecting projects carefully
The Mama principle is tied into what we call our “qualification criteria”, this is a list of questions we have to ask and answer about any project before we choose to work on it. It’s a long list which we should probably publish in the future, but it contains questions like:
- do we have the right skills to do this job?
- have we got a better way than what they’ve described?
- will we learn something new doing this?
- is the project morally and ethically something we want to do?
It means that sometimes we’ve said “no” to projects even when things were tight in year one. However, it’s had a very measurable long term impact as clients have realised we aren’t chasing money, we’re focused on doing the right thing for them and for us.
For example, we had to say no to working on a project because we didn’t have the time and people we thought would be right to work on this project. This is the response we got from the project owner who we then went on to work with on a much larger project later on.
“I completely understand! It’s a shame as I obviously wanted to work with you all again, but it’s the right thing for you to bid for work that you know you can deliver to the high standard we all know you work to. If you didn’t feel it was right, then that’s your call, and I think it says a lot (of good things) about the type of company you are that you made the call in the best interests of the work.”
Evidence behind the other three principles
Principle 2: Our profit funds innovation
We work on client work four days a week and save the fifth day for working on our own projects. When we first started Chris Dymond gave me some advice about this model. He said a lot of agencies do this 20% time (which references Google’s old model) but they often forget to make it contractual i.e. you can work on your own projects but it’s unclear who owns the work you do.
I think that’s another good example of how easy it would be to just write a set of principles without actually backing it up with evidence. So, when we needed our first employee contracts we invested in a bespoke clause which makes it clear to people who work at Paper they own the majority stake (over 50%) in any R&D work they do. To date, this time has led to innovations such as the legup.social events, a user research consent form process that’s been adopted by many of our clients, and some other interesting product and service ideas which we’re keeping under wraps for now.
Principle 3: We value leg ups and free work as much as paid work
This principle is fairly straightforward, if we find a project that meets our criteria but the organisation can’t pay for it, we do it for free. It’s led to some of the most valuable learning experiences we’ve had and some of the most rewarding work.
For example, we recently worked with Opt Out Tools to learn about ways to support people being misogynistically attacked on Twitter. The work gave us an opportunity to learn about: how to protect your participants and your team when working on a distressing subject and how to handle Becoming a target of online harassment ourselves.
To date we’ve done 5 full legup projects and helped over 150 charities and small businesses via the legup social events.
Principle 4: Paper is self funded and independent
This principle effectively means that we don’t have any financial bias. Paper is a specialist research and design studio, it’s important to our clients that they know we don’t have any preferred partners and they can rely on us to give impartial advice.
This has led to projects where organisations like the Department for Education, Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer, and the Co-op have been faced with large scale technology purchasing decisions e.g. Microsoft vs Google and iPhone vs Android, and have relied on Paper’s user research to provide unbiased evidence of the technology that best meets the needs of their teams. These have been multi-million pound decisions so it’s crucial that there’s no hint of financial bias in our recommendations.
Thinking long term
All the principles have this sort of balancing act between short term worry for long term benefit. We also need to acknowledge that it is a privilege that we are able to uphold our principles. It’s not always been easy and we are proud that we have upheld them but it’s still a privilege nonetheless.
I’m glad we wrote them down when we were skint and didn’t have any work, it’s made it easier to stick to them. The times when we’ve turned down work without knowing what’s coming next were scary at first, but as we’ve built our cash reserves and learned what work our team are best at, it’s been less scary and we’ve grown more and more confident.
The next step for us is to expand the structures that tie into our principles. Much like how qualifying work is tied to the Mama principle, we’re looking at how our policies and processes at Paper are all tied directly to a set of principles that reflect who we are and what we think is the right thing to do in each scenario.
For now, if you do want to work with Paper, hopefully this article goes some way to demonstrating that our principles aren’t bullshit, we legitimately follow them, and we’ve got the evidence to prove it.
Follow Paper on LinkedIn