Skip to content
A picture of Rachael
Rachael
User researcher

8 min read

Follow Paper on LinkedIn

How to protect your participants and your team when working on a distressing subject

An article about the steps you can take to protect your participants and your team from getting overwhelmed when you’re researching a distressing subject like misogynistic abuse.

We recently worked on a project to try and understand a bit more about women who regularly receive misogynistic abuse while using Twitter for work or activism. You can read more about what the aims of that project were here, and you can read a bit about how the recruitment process for this project wasn’t exactly ideal here.

This article is focused on our experience of running a research project where the subject matter is distressing, we’ll focus on setting it up safely for both the participants and the researchers. But before we get into that, it’s important to explain this strange relationship which has developed between using Twitter for work and the amount of abuse people recieve.

For many roles Twitter is absolutely essential, as a society we expect publicly facing people to share their thoughts, ideas and work on Twitter so that we know that they are relevant and we can understand what they are trying to do. Think about our prominent politicians, we absolutely expect to know them, understand their views and read about their stances on issues that are important to us. It’s how we connect in the modern world. At the same time, society seems to have simply accepted that this level of prominence automatically comes with some level of harassment, particularly when it comes to women and non-binary people. Most people you speak to will have noticed this problem, but we don’t seem to give it that much thought or talk about it often enough. Why should the cost of prominence be that you are constantly harassed for being a certain gender and having an opinion?

So, back to this project. Throughout our work to understand the experiences of people receiving misogynistic abuse online we’ve had some brilliant highs and some devastating lows on this journey. We felt that it’s important for us as researchers and designers to talk about the impact this can have on us and the work we’re doing.

Conducting research on sensitive subjects

At Paper we’re always mindful about the pressure that our participants may feel in our research sessions and always spend time at the start of a session to make sure the participant feels comfortable and in control.

As we knew we were asking people to share stories that may be traumatic for them to relive, we put extra effort into cultivating psychological safety for our participants.

We made sure to;

  • Regularly remind our participants that they could stop whenever they needed to
  • Remind them that they should skip any details they didn’t want to share
  • Be vigilant for signs of distress from our participants
  • Explain how we would protect their personal information and identities so they didn’t worry that they may face more abuse for taking part in our research

When we had finished with our questions, we always checked how our participants were feeling, and made sure that we had time to let them talk about how they had found the session in general. We also had a list of supportive organisations that focused on individuals that were experiencing online abuse that we offered to share with anyone who wanted it.

We’re also no strangers to the impact of research on the mental wellbeing of our researchers and have lots of support in place to help us manage this. We made sure that there were always two Paper people in the research sessions and spent as much time as we needed decompressing and talking about how it made us feel as well.

Without giving ourselves that time to decompress and reflect after a session it would have been difficult for us to stay neutral when it came to analysis, and may have meant that we brought in our own biases and emotions into the fray. This is challenging enough on any project, but for a topic where there is such an imbalance of power between those being harassed and their harassers it was extremely difficult. Making sure we dealt with our raw emotions before it came to analysis was essential.

Analysing distressing content

One of the fundamental principles of being a good researcher is your ability to remain neutral and not distort your findings by bringing in your own biases and experiences into the results.

This topic was always going to be difficult to analyse for a number of reasons. Not only was it infuriating hearing about people who were simply trying to make the world a better place being harassed because of their gender, but we were being exposed to the details of a really dark side to society. On top of this, we also had a recent dogpiling, (the act of a group of people joining in directing critical or abusive comments at another person or group), experience as a team, which was only a fraction of what our participants face on a daily basis. Bringing those factors into an already difficult situation meant I often found myself struggling to maintain my neutrality.

I often felt my own heart race and occasionally became distressed when reading about other people’s experiences and sometimes found myself projecting what I thought would have helped me into what participants were actually saying. Thankfully we are a very open team and I always knew I could talk through what I was feeling and be gently reminded that this project wasn’t about my feelings. By being allowed to space to calm down, acknowledge and accept my own feelings on the subject, I was much better prepared to continue analysing the content neutrally and think about where the themes were for our participants.

We went into this knowing that we’d need to have a plan for how to decompress during analysis. So we agreed some tactics in advance, such as;

  • Taking frequent breaks away from the results
  • Checking in and out of every analysis session
  • Not working alone
  • Switching from one story to another if we were finding it particularly distressing

We also made sure we frequently revisited the analysis that we had done to make sure we hadn’t brought in any bias to it and that we were representing what our users had told us.

For this team I feel like doing the analysis was cathartic in it’s own way, we could visually see how we could take this distressing information and use it in a way that may help someone facing these problems in the future. Wrapping all the information up and playing it back to each other felt quite empowering, we were all able to start to see a future where maybe misogyny online wouldn’t silence anyone who had something to say.

What we learned

While we may have found the topic difficult, we have also grown and learned so much about how we will handle distressing topics in our work going forward. Some of them we were already practicing and now have a renewed appreciation for, while others we have learned through this project

  • Check in and out of everything. Do them with your team, with your participants in your sessions, with anyone you talk to about this subject. Trying to act like you don’t have emotions in these situations will not serve you, so talk about them and let people help you when they can.
  • Think about what help you can offer to your participants. If you’re asking people to relive potentially traumatic events, make sure you can offer help to them after the session. If someone is distressed stay on the call with them until they feel comfortable to continue with their day, and have something you can send them for future help if they need it.
  • Give yourself enough time. Make sure you plan in the time to relax and have space away from the content. It may take longer to finish the analysis, but you shouldn’t be racing against a clock. You need the headspace to do this well, and to not feel a time pressure as well as an emotional pressure.
  • Find a way to switch off. It doesn’t matter what your personal approach to self-care is, but you should find something that helps you switch off at the end of a difficult day. Try to find something that takes up so much space in your brain that you don’t think about what you had to talk about in the day. Personally I’m a big fan of doing crochet as I can’t think about anything when I’m counting stitches!