Client: Department for Work and Pensions (DWP)
The challenge
A lot of organisations are trying to find a position to take on people using personal devices (phones, iPads, etc.) for work. Certainly, most organisations acknowledge that people are probably using personal devices for work. This begs the question of whether it is better to formally bring those devices into a safe and secure space or continue to ignore the security concerns.
Most organisations acknowledge that if there is a genuine need for someone to use a device for work, then they, the employer, should be providing it and not expecting people to use their own tech. However, it still happens. Some people prefer to use their personal device over work devices, while others like to have oversight of work and personal information all in one place.
There is an approach that some organisations have adopted where they formally allow people to use personal devices for work, if they choose, and place some restrictions around it. This is sometimes called Bring Your Own Device (BYOD)* and is something that the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has been assessing.
Like all government departments, DWP holds important data that must be kept safe and secure. The department and people working in the department take this responsibility extremely seriously—especially when it comes to technology and work devices.
DWP wants to modernise and support employees to work in a way that suits them, but using personal devices for work can raise concerns. For that reason, it’s not something that can be implemented quickly and without a lot of careful thought. DWP has been methodical, practical, and considered in their approach. They asked Paper to independently and comprehensively understand the reasons that people might choose to use their personal device for work, the risks to them, the risks to DWP, and the evidence they needed to weigh up in their decision-making.
The work
Our objectives were to understand the perception of this potential new service among DWP colleagues, highlight the risks, and prototype and test how to make it reliable and easy to use.
We worked as part of a multidisciplinary team within DWP to conduct research with colleagues piloting an early iteration of the service, and to engage colleagues across the department to understand their views on the service.
We conducted 37 interviews, 22 usability tests, a three-month diary study, and a large-scale survey to understand how colleagues would receive the service, how it would impact the department and staff, and whether the service was reliable and easy to use.
Our research uncovered strong opinions about this new service. People welcomed and worried about it in equal measure:
Benefits
- Many users welcomed this service as a way to save public money.
- The ergonomics and interfaces of personal devices are a much bigger benefit than we might’ve originally assumed. It’s not just comfort, it makes things easier and quicker for some users.
- Some people felt that only having to remember one device would be enough of a benefit to them to choose to use this service rather than continue using a DWP mobile device.
- Some people with conditions and disabilities said they would find it easier to use their personal device for work, which was already tailored to their needs.
- Some people believed it would make their work more secure on public transport if they received work messages or information.
Worries
- Some people were concerned about being able to keep their work life separate from their personal life.
- Some people were concerned about the data cost and/or the storage space.
- Suitability of devices was a worry for some people, and this also led to concerns about whether it might make their device harder to use in some way.
- There were concerns about DWP having access and control of personal devices and understanding the boundaries.
- Security of DWP data on personal devices was one of the most common concerns—something that everyone at DWP takes very seriously.
We also tested different elements of how the service might work. We conducted research with a small pilot of just over 30 people using a version of the service that was limited to Microsoft applications. We prototyped and tested changes to the guidance and policies surrounding using personal devices for work. In both cases, we were able to provide recommendations about the scope of the service (what should and shouldn’t be included) and the operational elements surrounding the service, i.e. guidance changes, policy changes, and support requirements.
This means that should DWP choose to continue to develop the service, they can be confident about what work needs to be done to make it a valuable, usable, and secure service.
Our role was to share what we were learning in the open so that people working at DWP could start to consider the implications for themselves and their colleagues. We held regular show and tells and invited feedback from over a thousand people working in the department.
The result
In an organisation with over 100,000 members of staff, a service like this can change the way people work.
To aid decision-making, we wrote up our findings in a long-form report. Usually, we avoid these sorts of things as they don’t get read, but in this case, it was clear that stakeholders throughout the organisation were very motivated to get into the details.
We shared the report and the key findings from our research with the team and senior leaders. Next, the decision to move ahead with this service is being sent up the chain to the highest levels of DWP. We’re pleased to say that our work will give them a clear-eyed view of the pros and cons of the service and the work that would need to be done if they choose to go ahead.
“It was great having Cam and the team from Paper conducting user research on bringing DWP access to users’ mobiles. The work generated insights that helped our understanding of the appetite for such a solution amongst our colleagues and the considerations for designing the service before we roll it to our users. The insights were also key in making decisions and a part of presenting the case to senior leadership. Cam and the team from Paper were very friendly, professional, and helpful all through the work and a genuine pleasure to work with. Cam also shared his expertise with the DWP team helping them upskill, helped improve processes through positive challenges, and contributed to help improve our ways of working. A big thank you for all the effort to help us design a better service for our users.”
– Sushant Pandey, Digital Product Manager
Chat with the Paper team
We're not salesy people, we'll say if we think we can help. Book a meeting with us and we'll give you advice based on our experience and capabilities.
“We will look back in five years’ time and say that Paper saved us a lot of effort, time and money.”
Stephen Betts, CEO Learn Sheffield
Tags related to this post: User Research, Service Design, BYOD, Digital Transformation, Data Security, Government Services, User-Centred Design, Process Improvement, Workplace Technology, Employee Experience