Skip to content
A picture of Mark, Cam, Jon
Mark, Cam, Jon
Directors

6 min read

Follow Paper on LinkedIn

Publishing data about representation, retention, pay and promotion at Paper (2022)

We published our first article on this subject a year ago and committed to sharing this data annually. This article provides an annual update on the four areas we covered previously; representation, retention, pay and promotion.

This year we have introduced employee satisfaction ratings from Glassdoor.

Representation

Last year we talked about how we didn’t collect data on the Paper team on gender, age, sexual orientation, disability, socio-economic status, religion. We did want to capture this information and to refresh it annually. We have made some progress in how we capture personally identifiable data but currently we do not ask the team for this special category data.

We have improved our process and data collection for working with freelancers to exceed GDPR requirements and to also capture anonymous information about ethnic groups, age, gender and disabilities or long-term health conditions.

This is the first step towards recording this information.

Retention

Last year we wrote “No-one has yet decided that Paper isn’t the right place for them. Writing those words makes us very happy indeed. It’s only a matter of time before this changes, and when it does we will be thoughtful, reflective, and supportive.”

This year has been a turbulent year for Paper, (which you can read more about) and it put those words into practice as some of the team decided to leave the business due to the risk of redundancy. Last year was a tough time for the team and the business.

We said last year that ‘retention’ is an odd thing to measure. It’s good in some ways but in another way it makes it sound like a trap. For some people, leaving Paper wasn’t a choice, for others it was. We built a team that included people new to the field without experience. It’s great to see people leave the business happy, leave with new capabilities and the ability to quickly get jobs in their specialisms.

We’re not shying away from anything, so below is the retention percentage of employees:

  • 2018 - 100%
  • 2019 - 100%
  • 2020 - 100%
  • 2021 - 100%
  • 2022 - 20%

Employee satisfaction at Paper

This year we began encouraging the whole team to provide feedback on their experience working at Paper. We decided to use a market leading employer review website called Glassdoor.

We believe this is more valuable insight into working at Paper than our retention rates, and particularly retention rates for the past year.

We asked all current and former employee’s to review us and we’re proud to say we currently have a 5 star rating.

An image from Glassdoor showing a 5 star rating for Paper from employees

Note: this is the score as of 22nd March 2023, for the live score please see the footer or Paper’s public Glassdoor page]

The feedback we received showed that even after a tough year for the business people were still happy to have worked for Paper.

We also received a 5 star rating for culture and values, an important aspect to working at Paper.

“Paper is a special place to be. I worked at Paper for a year and I always felt empowered and supportive from everyone at Paper but especially the directors.”

“It’s hard to put into words how wonderful it was to work at Paper! They are the first company I’ve worked for that truly lives and stands by their principles.”

You can read all of the feedback about working at Paper on our public Glassdoor page.

Employee pay

We’re really proud to say, again, that salaries for employees have increased over the past year. We ended 2022 bringing forward salary reviews ahead of time, so we’ve shared that below.

We worked hard to do this given the financial worries people are experiencing with the cost of living crisis and inflation amongst other things. It felt good wrapping up last year doing this, especially providing our highest average increases after the year it’d been.

Average salary annual increases:

  • 2018 - 8.5% increase
  • 2019 - 9% increase
  • 2020 - 5% increase
  • 2021 - 9% increase
  • 2022 - 8% increase
  • 2023 - 10% increase

Director pay

No change on this from last year. There’s three directors at Paper and we haven’t increased our pay over the past few years. We don’t take bonuses or additional compensation. Our pay is lower than benchmark salaries for leadership roles or even lead specialists roles. We do make contributions to a company pension when we think it’s appropriate and the last contribution was in 2021.

We do all this so that we continue to prioritise reinvesting profit into the business and Paper’s savings. Without this approach, we’d have had to make some tough decisions much earlier last year. This is something we are looking to review this year.

The percentage has been calculated by the difference between pay from 1 April to 31 March following each year. Numbers have been rounded down.

  • 2018 - 14.5% increase
  • 2019 - 25.5% increase
  • 2020 - 0% increase
  • 2021 - 0% increase
  • 2022 - 0% increase

Promotion

As we mentioned last time, as a business that’s adopted a flat-as-possible structure, we don’t distinguish between levels of roles or any real kind of significant hierarchy which makes this tricky to discuss and provide valuable insight about working at Paper.

In January 2021 we introduced a capability framework which has two types of progression:

  • Core Paper capabilities that go from Learning, to Owning, to Leading
  • Specialism capabilities which go from Learning, to Practising, to Specialising

In the second half of last year we changed emphasis of capability reviews from being requested by the team, rather than booked in by us. This, coupled with the slowdown of work, meant less focus on capability reviews and we haven’t tracked the benchmark of capability progression like we’d hoped.

We’ve also received feedback that this structure has some negative aspects to it, which I think we’d like to address this year.

Promotions to date:

  • 2018 - none
  • 2019 - none
  • 2020 - none
  • 2021 - none
  • 2022 - n/a

Thank you to each and everyone that has supported Paper over the past year.

If you’ve kept an eye on Paper over the years, you’ll know we’re ok with often opening ourselves up to critique and comments.

If you read this and want to get in touch about any of it, we’d love to hear from you.